Menu of Smoky Mountain Sub Shop by Sandwich Mamas in Waynesville, North Carolina, USA

Menu Overview

Located in the heart of Waynesville, North Carolina, Smoky Mountain Sub Shop by Sandwich Mamas offers a standout experience in the sandwich shop category. From my visits and the voices of loyal patrons, it’s clear this eatery blends quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation to create memorable meals that resonate with both locals and visitors alike.

The menu at Smoky Mountain Sub Shop is a well-curated collection of classics and creative twists. The Cuban Sandwich shines as a flagship item—layers of tender roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard pressed perfectly, delivering a harmonious balance of smoky, savory, and tangy flavors. Customers, like Nickolas Whidden, rave about its persistent excellence, highlighting it as a must-try dish that captures the essence of authentic sandwich craft.

Another signature offering is the Italian Mama Bomb Sub. While some guests have noted it’s somewhat smaller than expected, its blend of Italian cold cuts, provolone, and zesty peppers offers a satisfying, flavorful bite reminiscent of traditional deli fare. The classic Meatball Sub with Peppers & Onions is another hearty choice, featuring tender meatballs nestled in fresh bread with vibrant peppers and onions that amplify texture and depth.

Beyond subs, the Pimento Cheese Burger and the Honey Ham with Gruyere on a pretzel bun have earned high marks for their inventive approach. The pimento cheese adds a creamy, tangy punch to the burger, while the ham and Gruyere pairing provides a rich, indulgent profile, perfectly complemented by the slightly sweet, chewy pretzel bun—an “off the charts” favorite noted by longtime patrons.

Snacks and sides aren't overlooked here. The Chips offer a crisp, fresh crunch that pairs well with sandwiches, while salads like the Antipasto Salad provide a lighter but flavorful alternative for those seeking variety. The inclusion of cheese pizza rounds out the menu, catering to both traditionalist tastes and family crowds.

Service and atmosphere, even with takeout-only modifications during challenging times, remain an integral part of the dining experience. Staff members are frequently described as warm, attentive, and personalized in their service. This echoes Tohi Lucas’s and Austin Hart’s testimonials about the team’s care and consistency, adding a layer of community and comfort to every order.

Portion sizes are another highlight. Johnny Ringo points to generous servings, matched with fresh ingredients and appealing prices. The bread, a foundational element in every sub, stands out for its softness and freshness, crucial for delivering the right texture contrasts and holding up to robust fillings.

Overall, Smoky Mountain Sub Shop by Sandwich Mamas is a gem for anyone seeking satisfying, well-crafted sandwiches that honor tradition while embracing local flavor nuances. Whether you crave a classic cheesesteak, the robust Italian Mama Bomb, or a richly layered burger with unique cheese selections, this shop consistently delivers quality and heart in every bite.